Tommy Meehan wrote:First of all, I can't believe many people are going to be riding "regular service" from this station. Even during the transit strike of a few years ago few people rode from the temporary Yankee Stadium stop. It's too far from River Avenue/Grand Concourse where the population is. You'll have to walk right past the 161st Street No.4/D train station to get to Metro-North. And Metro-North won't match the frequency of service/lower fare of the subway.
The subway doesn't go to Yonkers, Tarrytown, or other employment centers along the Hudson, and stations in the Bronx tend to be used more by reverse commuters than people going to Midtown.
Sarge wrote:There really is nothing near the new station, and the new stadium is farther away from the new stadium than the old one. Still, I think it will be pretty well patronized by fans, as parking can be pretty steep, and pretty far, too. You do have some old walkups and some homes near the area. There are also projects across the Harlem River that I think, since the abandonment of the 9th Av El stub, are not served by subway/rail. The development was supposed to be mixed use; residential and retail. I doubt that would have added sufficient population to make it worthy as a commuter stop.
Over and above the Stadium traffic, this is a perfect place to put a Metro-North station. It will be well used on non-game days. This is the densely populated South Bronx. There are more people living within a half-mile radius of this station than the majority of suburban stations. Look at an aerial photo of the area. You have
one block next to the station that is used for parking. There are not a lot of Metro-North stations that don't have parking lots nearby. East of River Avenue you have block after block full of large six-story apartment buildings. I live in one of those buildings and plan to walk to this station every day.
Besides this, there is the
Gateway Center at the Bronx Terminal Market opening this fall adjacent to the station's west side. (
Here is how construction is coming along as of March 21.) This is an 18-acre, 2.25 million-square-foot mall of big box stores including Applebee's, Babies R Us, Bed, Bath & Beyond, Best Buy, BJ's, Home Depot, Marshall's, Staples, Target and Toys R Us. It does not have a residential component and I am not aware that it ever was supposed to have had one. However, it is planned to have a 225-room hotel adjacent to the station (although with the downturn in the economy who knows). Shoppers will have the option of taking Metro-North to this mall, and it will house 1,921 jobs. Many of those employees will be able to commute via Metro-North. The County Courthouse and numerous other courthouses are within walking distance as well. Many people use the Melrose station to commute to jobs at these courthouses, and now people from the Hudson Line will be able to do the same.
Looking at the bigger picture, the Bronx has a population of 1,369,859 per the latest census estimate, but has just 12 (soon to be 13) Metro-North stations. For comparison, Westchester County has 949,041 residents but has 43 Metro-North stations. And 77% of households in the Yankee Stadium neighborhood, like mine,
have no car. Many others have only one car, so commuting by train allows the other spouse to use the car.