Railroad Forums 

  • Rail and Autonomous Trucks

  • For topics on Class I and II passenger and freight operations more general in nature and not specifically related to a specific railroad with its own forum.
For topics on Class I and II passenger and freight operations more general in nature and not specifically related to a specific railroad with its own forum.

Moderator: Jeff Smith

 #1594579  by John_Perkowski
 
Link: Trains put up an analysis or op Ed piece on rail v autonomous trucking.

My two cents: There is a tremendous amount of road and traffic signaling infrastructure to be done in the US before the last 25 miles at each end (manufacturer to highway and highway to consignee) are ready for autonomous shipping by street.
 #1594582  by scratchyX1
 
John_Perkowski wrote: Tue Mar 29, 2022 11:41 am Link: Trains put up an analysis or op Ed piece on rail v autonomous trucking.

My two cents: There is a tremendous amount of road and traffic signaling infrastructure to be done in the US before the last 25 miles at each end (manufacturer to highway and highway to consignee) are ready for autonomous shipping by street.

Plus, liability and inclement weather functionality,
not to mention, what to do when the OS has a 10 year old exploit that allows someone to just have them diverted,
so no messy packages on ROW's when they get hacked.
 #1596558  by Engineer Spike
 
Recently the governor of The People's Republic of New York decreed that internal combustion vehicles will be outlawed within the next 25 years. Unless batteries improve markedly by then, they won't really be practical for long distance runs. For this I see two possible solutions. The first is that intermodal is used for long distance runs, and motor transport for the local drayage. With charging times being prohibitive, one solution may be to have replaceable battery packs.

I can see the points about how autonomous trucks can't adjust for poor road conditions... Maybe speed isn't what they'd go for. With no human contact, maybe a dedicated 30 mph road may be all that's needed. There would be no rush to fit in as many hours as possible into a driver's allowable driving periods.