Wikipedia says Bloomingburg, NY used to be a railroad town before a fire in 1922. It also says, however, that neither the Erie nor the NYO&W had a station in the town.
I'm going to hedge my bets and ask if the Middletown and Crawford, the railroad that replaced the local turnpike, was the one that had a station there.
I'm going to hedge my bets and ask if the Middletown and Crawford, the railroad that replaced the local turnpike, was the one that had a station there.