by airman00
One other point I might make is that, at the time of the "failure", she was a solid 45 years old. Not to mention as well, she was the last of the six alco s-2 switchers still hanging around. The other five were already gone, and #206 was still going strong. Finally the #206 had a problem and maybe she was repairable and the NYS&W still needed her. But maybe they decided that it wasn't worth it to repair a 45 yr. old engine, even though she was "rebuilt" not too long ago, and instead sidelined her until they decided to make a final desicion.
In any event, the reason I am so persistent, is that I was considering starting up an effort to see her running on the rails again. I just didn't want to be an "I love trains" railfan, and sit on the sidelines. Initially I would have said no way, since she had a "blown engine". But on doing some research and digging for clues on her past and the supposed "failure" of the prime mover, I just think something other than a blown engine did her in, and she may still be salvageable. What did her in must've been just enough to not warrant a full repair and instead to sideline her. However...I wanted to get input and feedback, hoping to unlock more clues and thusly to come to a desicion as to whether or not mounting such an effort to get her going is even worth it. After all someone said it's better to be preserved than to be scrapped. it's just a shame she's done.
In any event, the reason I am so persistent, is that I was considering starting up an effort to see her running on the rails again. I just didn't want to be an "I love trains" railfan, and sit on the sidelines. Initially I would have said no way, since she had a "blown engine". But on doing some research and digging for clues on her past and the supposed "failure" of the prime mover, I just think something other than a blown engine did her in, and she may still be salvageable. What did her in must've been just enough to not warrant a full repair and instead to sideline her. However...I wanted to get input and feedback, hoping to unlock more clues and thusly to come to a desicion as to whether or not mounting such an effort to get her going is even worth it. After all someone said it's better to be preserved than to be scrapped. it's just a shame she's done.