by LCJ
I remember "way back in the day" when the first radio alarm detectors were installed on my home division (Mohawk-Hudson). I overheard a particular engineer, after pulling his train across one of these and getting the "all clear" message, gave a knee-jerk "roger that" response.
Coincidentally, the Div. Supt. happened to overhear this exchange. My immediate thought was "How dumb to answer a machine." Mr. Supt., however, thought is was a great idea -- and immediately made it a requirement on the division to answer the radio alarm -- for the benefit of the tape recording, and to help ensure that people were alert and in the game as they ran over the railroad.
I came to believe it was a good practice -- and still do. The NORAC folks (notably Alan Fisher, one of the organizers and a driving force of NORAC) thought it was a good idea, too.
Sometimes change for the sake of change is misguided, in my opinion.
Coincidentally, the Div. Supt. happened to overhear this exchange. My immediate thought was "How dumb to answer a machine." Mr. Supt., however, thought is was a great idea -- and immediately made it a requirement on the division to answer the radio alarm -- for the benefit of the tape recording, and to help ensure that people were alert and in the game as they ran over the railroad.
I came to believe it was a good practice -- and still do. The NORAC folks (notably Alan Fisher, one of the organizers and a driving force of NORAC) thought it was a good idea, too.
Sometimes change for the sake of change is misguided, in my opinion.