by Jack Shufelt
K4Pacific "I got the ICC report and gave it to Paul in the late 90s. He had a tear. He said all his mom got was a $30,000 settlement from the railroad on the operators mistake at HJ block station. When that op found out what happened he just ran off and was never heard from again."
I have some interest in the history of Himrod Junction and was curious about the wreck at Orleans, NY, so I pulled the ICC report. That report exonerates the operator at "JN" and the dispatcher. The report concludes that; "The accident was caused by the northbound train occupying a manual block without authority."
The operator spoke with the Extra 7103 south at 1.25 P.M. while he was at Newark and gave him permission to proceed south to Stanley and clear up for a northbound train. The operator also spoke with the Extra 7129 north and gave him permission to proceed to Bell. Extra 7129 passed Himrod Jct. at 1.59 P.M. For Extra 7129 to receive permission to pass more than one Block Limit Station it would have required a Clearance Card Form K authorized by the dispatcher and there is no record of that occurring.
The fireman on Extra 7129 north, the only survivor on the head end, was not personally aware of any authorization for his train to proceed beyond Bell. He "assumed" that the engineer had that permission as a result of a conversation between the head brakeman and the engineer, which he did not overhear. The head man came up from the second unit to talk to the engineer and then returned to it.
If I understand the Block Limit Rules correctly, without the Form K or additional radio or telephone authorization from the operator at "JN" the Extra 7129 North had no authority to proceed beyond Bell.
I have some interest in the history of Himrod Junction and was curious about the wreck at Orleans, NY, so I pulled the ICC report. That report exonerates the operator at "JN" and the dispatcher. The report concludes that; "The accident was caused by the northbound train occupying a manual block without authority."
The operator spoke with the Extra 7103 south at 1.25 P.M. while he was at Newark and gave him permission to proceed south to Stanley and clear up for a northbound train. The operator also spoke with the Extra 7129 north and gave him permission to proceed to Bell. Extra 7129 passed Himrod Jct. at 1.59 P.M. For Extra 7129 to receive permission to pass more than one Block Limit Station it would have required a Clearance Card Form K authorized by the dispatcher and there is no record of that occurring.
The fireman on Extra 7129 north, the only survivor on the head end, was not personally aware of any authorization for his train to proceed beyond Bell. He "assumed" that the engineer had that permission as a result of a conversation between the head brakeman and the engineer, which he did not overhear. The head man came up from the second unit to talk to the engineer and then returned to it.
If I understand the Block Limit Rules correctly, without the Form K or additional radio or telephone authorization from the operator at "JN" the Extra 7129 North had no authority to proceed beyond Bell.