Gilbert B Norman wrote:It appears that for Private Car owners, elimination of M&E has resulted in a "bennie"; their car can again be "properly pointed".
Allow me to correct you on the use of the proper terminology.
The traditional terminology for positioning a private car in the consist is "rearmost, properly pointed." The term is particularly relevant for observation cars, but not as relevant for other cars.
"Properly pointed" refers to which end of the car faces forward and which end faces rear. That is readily apparent with an observation car. For other cars (such as sleepers, coaches, lounges and diners), which were not specifically designed for end of train service, one end of the car is usually preferred as the leading end; this usually reflects interior arrangements such as which way some/all beds/seats face. In general, Amtrak has always been good at making sure the car is pointed in the manner desired by the owner, subject to some operating limitations. Properly pointed was not the problem.
"Rearmost" is just that ... the last piece of equipment in the consist ... the car carrying the marker light(s). This has been the problem on Amtrak. Owners of observation cars have had their view to the rear blocked by Roadrailers; the design of RoadRailers requires they operate rearmost. Owners of observation cars, who want to be plugged into HEP rather than running their generator for many hours, have had to sacrifice the rearmost position and have their view to the rear blocked by a HEP-less boxcar. Now that mail and bulk express is going away, there is a greater chance a private car can operate rearmost in the Amtrak consist, with nothing behind it to block the view to the rear.
The other plus of losing the RoadRailers and HEP-less boxcars from the rear of the consist is the increased opportunity to pickup/setout a private car at intermediate stops, given Amtrak's general unwillingness to doubleswitch a consist to pickup/setout a private car at intermediate stations. For example, the loss of the rear-end M&E traffic on The Southwest Chief may reopen Kansas City and the Grand Canyon area stations to PV traffic.