• A 'grim' fairy tale

  • Discussion relating to Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority (Philadelphia Metro Area). Official web site can be found here: www.septa.com. Also including discussion related to the PATCO Speedline rapid transit operated by Delaware River Port Authority. Official web site can be found here: http://www.ridepatco.org/.
Discussion relating to Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority (Philadelphia Metro Area). Official web site can be found here: www.septa.com. Also including discussion related to the PATCO Speedline rapid transit operated by Delaware River Port Authority. Official web site can be found here: http://www.ridepatco.org/.

Moderator: AlexC

  by JeffK
 
It's January 1, 2006 and the Philadelphia Transportation Company has been operating (if you could call it that) for four months. The PTC name and logo were resurrected last August when Mayor Street formally severed the city's association with the now-defunct SEPTA. The PTC receives only minimal state funding and the city is unable to provide much help either. The PTC runs what it calls its "4-5-6-7" service, charging a $4 base fare, with service operating 5 days a week from 6 a.m. to 7 p.m. Only a small portion of what once was a huge transit system remains - the BSS and MFSE, plus about a dozen feeder bus lines. Even the subway-surface trolleys now sit idle for want of money to keep them running.

Things came to a head in early 2005 when the state legislature and Governor Rendell played "chicken" but no one blinked. Republican leaders said that if the region really felt public transit was needed, Philadelphia and the suburban counties would find a way to pay. Gov. Rendell tried a band-aid fix by shifting some federal money to SEPTA but om June the state Supreme Court ruled that action was illegal. Bickering among the SEPTA board members led to a refusal by the suburban representatives to fund any service running into the city. As a result, in July the western side of the R5 (now called the Paoli Local again) was cut back to Overbrook, with riders being forced to transfer to a bus if they wanted to continue into the city. On the old Reading side, the R3 and R5 now end at Fern Rock, while the R2, R6, R7 and R8 are shut down entirely.

Three of the city's largest employers have announced plans to move out, despite previously-agreed tax incentives. Ace Ltd. is heading for Radnor, Comcast is looking at a new building in Conshohocken, and Towers Perrin will be consolidating all operations at its New Jersey facilities. The Gallery remained open on Saturdays during the 2005 Christmas holidays but effective today it will be closed on weekends. Over a dozen small merchants have already gone out of business and there are doubts about the viability of at least one major retailer. Business Week highlighted the situation in a cover story titled "Philly - Dying, or Already Dead?"

Delaware and Montgomery Counties jointly agreed to try to keep weekday operations on the 100, 101 and 102 rail lines going, although at reduced levels. The 101 line is still serving Springfield Mall, but with no direct transportation to places like Willow Grove and King of Prussia, those malls' operators have had to set up their own shuttle services to ferry workers to and from the nearest operating rail lines. Willow Grove has already eliminated Sunday hours; King of Prussia closes at 5 on Saturday and is only open from 12 to 4 on Sundays. They too may shut down on Sundays if post-Christmas traffic is not adequate. Sales are already off by about a quarter over 2004 and the malls' reduced tax revenue may force the surrounding municipalities to raise property taxes by as much as 17%.

And no one lived happily ever after.

  by Tadman
 
Meanwhile the roads are so overloaded it takes days to get from Norristown to downtown.

  by rob216
 
Sad, but possibly will be true.

  by walt
 
Where is Merritt H. Taylor, Jr. when you need him?
  by glennk419
 
JeffK wrote:It's January 1, 2006 and the Philadelphia Transportation Company has been operating (if you could call it that) for four months. The PTC name and logo were resurrected last August when Mayor Street formally severed the city's association with the now-defunct SEPTA. The PTC receives only minimal state funding and the city is unable to provide much help either. The PTC runs what it calls its "4-5-6-7" service, charging a $4 base fare, with service operating 5 days a week from 6 a.m. to 7 p.m. Only a small portion of what once was a huge transit system remains - the BSS and MFSE, plus about a dozen feeder bus lines. Even the subway-surface trolleys now sit idle for want of money to keep them running.

Things came to a head in early 2005 when the state legislature and Governor Rendell played "chicken" but no one blinked. Republican leaders said that if the region really felt public transit was needed, Philadelphia and the suburban counties would find a way to pay. Gov. Rendell tried a band-aid fix by shifting some federal money to SEPTA but om June the state Supreme Court ruled that action was illegal. Bickering among the SEPTA board members led to a refusal by the suburban representatives to fund any service running into the city. As a result, in July the western side of the R5 (now called the Paoli Local again) was cut back to Overbrook, with riders being forced to transfer to a bus if they wanted to continue into the city. On the old Reading side, the R3 and R5 now end at Fern Rock, while the R2, R6, R7 and R8 are shut down entirely.

Three of the city's largest employers have announced plans to move out, despite previously-agreed tax incentives. Ace Ltd. is heading for Radnor, Comcast is looking at a new building in Conshohocken, and Towers Perrin will be consolidating all operations at its New Jersey facilities. The Gallery remained open on Saturdays during the 2005 Christmas holidays but effective today it will be closed on weekends. Over a dozen small merchants have already gone out of business and there are doubts about the viability of at least one major retailer. Business Week highlighted the situation in a cover story titled "Philly - Dying, or Already Dead?"

Delaware and Montgomery Counties jointly agreed to try to keep weekday operations on the 100, 101 and 102 rail lines going, although at reduced levels. The 101 line is still serving Springfield Mall, but with no direct transportation to places like Willow Grove and King of Prussia, those malls' operators have had to set up their own shuttle services to ferry workers to and from the nearest operating rail lines. Willow Grove has already eliminated Sunday hours; King of Prussia closes at 5 on Saturday and is only open from 12 to 4 on Sundays. They too may shut down on Sundays if post-Christmas traffic is not adequate. Sales are already off by about a quarter over 2004 and the malls' reduced tax revenue may force the surrounding municipalities to raise property taxes by as much as 17%.

And no one lived happily ever after.
Jeff, well written, I just hope it's not too prophetic. Have you thought of mailing a copy of this to Governor Rendell, City Hall and the county commissioners? Might as well send a copy off to DVARP and DVRPC while you're at it.
  by JeffK
 
glennk419 wrote:Have you thought of mailing a copy of this to Governor Rendell, City Hall and the county commissioners? Might as well send a copy off to DVARP and DVRPC while you're at it.
This was mostly a vent in a supportive forum. Sadly I've spent nearly 20 years trying to get the ears of everyone from local news media to the Governor(*), but the theme of virtually every response I've ever received has been, "Thanks for your opinions, I'm glad you wrote, and please vote for me in the next election."

I hate to say it, but the only way this will play out is when the buses and trains stop running. Maybe not even then.

:( :( :(


(*) To name a few:
Ed Rendell
Michael Nutter
Wilson Goode Jr.
Jon Fox
Peter Quinn
Jere Downs
Dick Standish
Fox-29 Undercover
All 3 Montco commissioners
Wally Nunn

  by SEPTALRV9072
 
Try NBC 10. They're always thirsty for a story and will bring a tabloidesque slant to the story.

  by Matthew Mitchell
 
I think Jeff's worst case scenario here shows a lot of understanding of the situation and of history, but in all reality, it is extremely unlikely--particularly the idea of a Chinese Wall at the city line. Sububan interests including elected officials and business people, would have little reason to support a system that did not go into the city, not to mention that the economics of such a truncated system would be awful, so there would be a complete shutdown rather than that kind of city/suburb division.

If a breakup of the system were to follow a somewhat vehement argument between city and suburban interests, I can't see the railroad stopping at the city line: first because so much of the system serves only city stations or has a substantial city component (e.g. R7 at Torresdale), and second because of the number of employers who rely on the system.

Now Street or Council might want to be that vindictive, but there'd be enough people who understand the consequences that they'd step in and prevent it.

The possibility of the legislature calling Rendell's bluff and not funding SEPTA is real. See Buffalo for a precedent, though it didn't necessarily come about the same way. Rendell is putting his desire for a political victory (or some other unfathomable priority) ahead of solving the problem. His previous excusemaking doesn't really hold water, given how little attention he has paid to the problem.

And yes, John Street has been deplorably AWOL on the matter too, and he doesn't have Comcast Sports Net to blame. (apologies to Creighton)

  by walt
 
This "ficticious" ( but highly prophetc) scenareo is really not that far from the 1950's- 60's situation that resulted in the creation of SEPTA in the first place. The PTC and Red Arrow Lines were separate companies ( with the PTC opposing every plan advanced by the several Merritt Taylors to run Red Arrow vehicles into Center City) with no transfer privileges between routes of the two companies, particularly at 69th Street. What is now the RRD were separate suburban services operated by the PRR and Reading Railroads--- two entities that didn't communicate with each other at all. What is now the Frontier Division consisted of a number of small suburban bus companies, with little coordination among them AND---- other than the Red Arrow Lines, nobody was making any money.------- The more things change---- the more they stay the same!

  by nickrapak
 
It's 12/28/05, and SEPTA is running as usual (not very well). There was het sacre with the strike, but all's "well" that ends "well"!