Oh, I see what you are saying - yea, probably, the '44 would have broken down anyway more than likely anyway, with or without passengers, so cancelling that eastbound train and making the passegners catch the next one just happened to be the right decision, because those people would have had to catch that train anyway, because the eariler one broke down.
As for making arraignments for other crews, I supposed they could have, but the only places were they would be able to get crews from would either be if tehre was a crew adn train sitting in Sunnyside yard, just hanging out (i have no idea if there is or not, but I doubt there is) or a yard crew, from the MMC. They could have brought themselves and equipment to NYP and ran the westbound, however, they have their own things to do, and who knows, they might not have even been anywhere near the Club - they might have been on an equipment move to AC, or fueling out in Raritan, or heading down to Morrisville, etc.
Especially late at nights on the weekends, the crews are really on their own - there is noone around - you do what you have to do to get that train going becuase its your train for the night, and its your ride home (often times on the weekend, the crews will keep the same equipment for at least two trains.) So if that train breaks down, "we're going into our time", as we like to say, and if we don't get that thing going, we are sitting somewhere for a LOOOOONG time. But the breakdown in Hazlet was nothing that could have been fixed by the engineer, as the air compressor in the motor spewed all its oil over the engine room.....
On the RR, "believe nothing you hear and only half of what you see"
John, aka "JTGSHU" passed away on August 26, 2013. We honor his memory and his devotion to railroading at railroad.net.