by CRail
Easy there tiger.
Lines catch on as people realize the benefits of using them, it takes a while to change people's habits. Most new business take about 5 years before they're going full swing, and this is comparable to a new branch of a company. Getting into the city on the expressway is miserable, but word on the street is so is taking the train (I choose driving over transit whenever possible and I'm a fan of transit, figure that one out). People for one reason or another may have to try it once, and if they like it they'll stay. Word of mouth factors in here. The remaining people are surely only a trickle, but that's enough to get the ball rolling.
Arlington, your data is also emphasized to lead us to your position. The HALF BILLION (oh my, the state spent a lot of money as usual) dollars was not spent for the alleged initial 950 riders to stop driving, it was spent for ALL the riders which will travel on the line throughout its existence. The line is not 70% under projection (I know you didn't say that, but you emphasized one detail in lieu of the big picture, which is my point), it is less than 50% under (according to the numbers presented). This is disappointing but not catastrophic in my opinion. My purpose here is not to say that the line was in fact worth while, because as I've stated I will reserve judgment until a time when I feel the line has had enough time to incur significant growth, and simply because I don't care. They aren't going to just stop running trains to Greenbush so I'm having trouble understanding what you're getting at.
I will admit, however, that when Ashland, Southborough, and Westborough stations opened on the Worcester line, it took almost no time at all before every rush hour train was met by a full platform at each stop. Again, if the numbers (which were provided by a media source) are accurate, then that is disappointing, but they don't mean to me that it's time to start ripping up tracks. I'm not that short sighted.
Lines catch on as people realize the benefits of using them, it takes a while to change people's habits. Most new business take about 5 years before they're going full swing, and this is comparable to a new branch of a company. Getting into the city on the expressway is miserable, but word on the street is so is taking the train (I choose driving over transit whenever possible and I'm a fan of transit, figure that one out). People for one reason or another may have to try it once, and if they like it they'll stay. Word of mouth factors in here. The remaining people are surely only a trickle, but that's enough to get the ball rolling.
Arlington, your data is also emphasized to lead us to your position. The HALF BILLION (oh my, the state spent a lot of money as usual) dollars was not spent for the alleged initial 950 riders to stop driving, it was spent for ALL the riders which will travel on the line throughout its existence. The line is not 70% under projection (I know you didn't say that, but you emphasized one detail in lieu of the big picture, which is my point), it is less than 50% under (according to the numbers presented). This is disappointing but not catastrophic in my opinion. My purpose here is not to say that the line was in fact worth while, because as I've stated I will reserve judgment until a time when I feel the line has had enough time to incur significant growth, and simply because I don't care. They aren't going to just stop running trains to Greenbush so I'm having trouble understanding what you're getting at.
I will admit, however, that when Ashland, Southborough, and Westborough stations opened on the Worcester line, it took almost no time at all before every rush hour train was met by a full platform at each stop. Again, if the numbers (which were provided by a media source) are accurate, then that is disappointing, but they don't mean to me that it's time to start ripping up tracks. I'm not that short sighted.
Moderator: Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority, Brightline Trains
Avatar:3679A (since wrecked)/3623B (now in service as 3636B).
Avatar:3679A (since wrecked)/3623B (now in service as 3636B).