I think it's clear (reading the back-and-forth) that there are some on this forum who are unapologetic believers in the glory of EHH and the PSR movement, and some who are unwavering in their (equally valid) views of EHH as a cult leader who forced people to drink the Cool-Aid of the PSR cult to their doom. I suspect that the truth lies somewhere in between. Since the railroad industry started almost 200 years ago, there have been waves of new or repackaged ideas that have swept through the industry. Some of them made things better, some of them made things worse, and some of them amounted to rearranging the deck chairs. Let's try to pull back from both PSR boosting and PSR bashing, and look at the larger picture. There are lots of things that have changed over the past six years that have had (and are having) an effect on the railroad industry. The use of (or lack of) various strategies labelled "PSR" is only a small part of that.