ant8904 wrote:Philip Wirth wrote:6/2/08 Meeting Minutes
According to page 6 of this document, the current plan is to extend the D branch through Union Square and to extend the E Branch through Medford.
If they choose to go with the "loop" option at Union Square, wouldn't that completely mess up the headways of the line that currently has the best, and the headways on the Medford extension could be bad, with the problems that can occur all the way back during the street-running section of the E Branch. The other problem that I see with this, is that the T needs to get around to running the Type 8's on Riverside, because wouldn't a new extension need to be ADA compliant, which the "loop" proposal using Type 7's would not be?
Well, they are suppose to get type 8 for the d line months ago, at the least, it should come by the time the expansion is completed anyway.
The loop option sounds a little convoluted to implement because of land-taking. Stub-end on the Fitchburg with tail tracks, compromise option as it is Square access-wise, at least fits on the existing ROW without problems. Yeah, the electrical substation is there and it's butt ugly, but isn't that easier property to build around than diverting off the ROW with residential/commercial land-taking. That just seems like a born delay to the project...get the friggin' trains running by keeping it simple! There's also no way you can extend one of the westbound lines out there with any amount of street or reservation-running. I also wouldn't want any alignment that precludes an extension to Porter tacked on later, because the Porter/Davis area will be screaming for it as soon as the shovels hit the ground and that really is the natural terminus because of the bus/Red/CR connections. It would also be cheap to do the rest of the jaunt once you get as far as Union.
I also think they can fit in that second Brickbottom station by maybe swapping it off the Lowell ROW onto the Fitchburg ROW right after the junction, putting it at McGrath and the shopping center, and building good ped access to the other side. Just a thought...would balance the branches a little so the West Medford one doesn't have one too many stations and the Union one too few.
Encouraging that D line speeds are projected for the area!