fogg1703 wrote:Now the question I have been wondering, could the P&W use its trackage rights and interchange with MC at Cotley? The P&W already interchanges with the MBTA at East Jct and they could travel north up the "freight track" to the Attleboro Secondary and then swap cars at Cotley Jct under their trackage agreement. l'm sure some P&W would be off CSX's Christmas card list if they ever pulled it off. Not saying they ever would but I suppose it could happen.
P&W has overhead-only rights on the Attleboro and Fall River branches, so they can't interchange directly in MC territory. Its local rights pick up at the Fall River/Tiverton border and run to Newport (yes, they've kept it all this time the bridge has been out...it's even on their system map). Right now that's exactly one potential customer, the gas tank farm on the Tiverton side of the border where the tracks end. They're currently barge/truck-only, but always a fair future bet for switching to rail. So MC is landlocked by CSX on all sides, and the only way to get around that is if MC got access on the NEC to East Junction Yard in P&W's south-of-Attleboro locals territory. Which CSX would obviously be insane to allow. Or I suppose P&W could be bastards and set up an interchange at that gas tank farm and exchange at the literal state line while going "Neener, neener! Can't touch me!" at CSX. But that's mutually assured destruction, and since MA and RI own the tracks they'd probably intervene real quick to prevent nuclear war between 3 carriers. Unlikely hypothetical; there's not nearly enough business at stake to make that stunt worth either P&W's or MC's while.
EDIT: Checking the system maps, P&W's local rights terminate at East Junction and are overhead-only north of there to Attleboro. CSX local rights extend south to East Jct. That means they could safely let MC vacuum up all locals on the Attleboro Sec. still served by CSX and sort for them at Middleboro interchange so long as MC's not allowed on the NEC.
I guess it all depends on how absolutist CSX wants to be about dumping all remaining locals in favor of interchange-only except for the areas that lack available or advisable shortlines (Boston/128 metro within 10 miles of Readville, Fitchburg Secondary, NEC odds-and-sods, etc.). Framingham increasingly doesn't seem to serve much purpose in the new yard order. If there were some expedited state-sponsored improvements to get the PAR Worcester Branch up to spec they could conceivably run the Everett Terminal job direct out of Worcester with the T granting them overhead rights on the Fitchburg Line east of Ayer (much lower commuter rail interference), as well as the Fitchburg Sec. job via Worcester-Clinton by re-laying the wye track. If the two Priscoli shortlines can take care of all their locals sorting needs and Readville gets a little bit of load-shifting recalibration to offset there's no reason why they can't run the Middleboro job straight direct out of Worcester. They can say to hell with Framingham and the aggravation of dealing with the locals, keep Nevins Yard as a skeletal stopover staffed remote out of Worcester the couple hours a day it's needed, let North and CP collect weeds and be tax revenue and employment black holes for the town until somebody steps up and meets their purchase price, and tell them to talk to the state or talk to the hand on running overhead through the grade crossings. Doesn't impact their revenue any more than the cost savings they return by consolidating, and they move the same exact goods to Worcester.
I guess what options go on the table depends on 1) whither Framingham's place in the pecking order and impact on locals capacity, and 2) whither locals streamlining as corporate policy and how resolute they want to be about consolidating or delegating every cost penny of non-interchange service at no net carload loss.
EDIT 2: I guess they could safely give G&U the Franklin Industrial Track and gamble on possibility of an exposed flank to Blackstone in 25 years if the agreement with G&U was booby-trapped to the hilt with fine print about only interchanging with them and never ever pulling any crap with P&W. Frowned-upon practice by the feds to put in those restrictions, but the legalese loopholes in the contracts are big enough to drive a double-stack through so the Class I's do it all the time. Pretty sure the MC rights transfer had all kinds of arcane gobbledygook in the agreement boxing them in to exclusive interchanging and de facto CSX approval on any expansion moves they make. It's how the game is played.