Jay, give it up! Look at the title of the thread: The LIRR is 170 years old today. And the Strasburg is a few months short of 172. Both of these are historical facts, based on charter dates. Strikes and temporary suspensions of service (due to lack of business) have nothing to do with the charter dates.
And I'll go along with this TrainLawyer guy on the MTA Long Island issue. Isn't that how some of the equipment is lettered? The LIRR is now operated by a government agency, while the Strasburg is in the hands of it's stockholders.
I'm not taking sides here, just pointing out the facts of the matter. I think both railroads are interesting, in their own way. I've been going to the Strasburg on and off since maybe 1960, and was involved in a LIRR restoration project many years ago. But once again, dates are dates and facts are facts.