High fares, low fares, or no fares I'm afraid that the grand experiment is going to be a complete waste of taxpayer dollars. Why? Well, the major reason is that there just isn't this pent up consumer demand in Western Mass to go to the big Apple.
The divine thinking on all this is that now that the Knowledge corridor is up and running at high speed, 70 in places, people in the Pioneer Valley will be hopping at the chance to take advantage of all the additional scheduling.
In the article, you will note that the local planner is opining that the new service will allow the public to travel to New York by train and back in one day. One very long day including 10 hours of train travel. Oh sure there may be a few people out there who will take advantage of that service. But how many people is the question.
By the same token, the article also mentions the fact that the service will facilitate people from NYC who want to go to Greenfield. Well I'm sure there must be at least three of those.
The Knowledge Corridor and connections to NYC is just not the same deal as the Downeaster. People from southern Maine do a lot of travel to and from Boston. And a lot of people from Boston do go to and from southern Maine. The NYC to Greenfield traffic dynamics however, just aren't there.