F3A wrote:I have said this all along, the drawbridge should have been replaced by two tunnels of two tracks each under Newark Bay.
Nearly 45 years on, and the so-called Aldene Plane still does not adequately serve the interests of the Raritan Valley line.
At the time of the Aldene Plan, the forecast was that commuter rail use would continue to decline and in a decade or so disappear entirely due to lack of demand. Note that a prime reason for Aldene was to eliminate the cost and time factor of the ferry operation. At that timeframe there was also serious consideration to extending PATH to Plainfield with a bus connection running on a paved CNJ mainline (leaving one track for freight) for connections to the west.
A much less expensive proposition was rebuilding a draw on one of the two track bridges over Newark Bay to be much wider and higher, but that still would not have eliminated the ferry cost; the parallel second bridge would have been abandoned and the center removed to match the width of the new draw. But that plan never seemed to gain any support except from the City of Bayonne.