No, just too many whining NIMBYs. Foolish idiots. Never let a fact get in the way. These giant freights would vineyard exactly? The line does dead end in Spring Valley. Frankly, I'm embarrassed to originally be from Hillsdale the way these small-minded mayors acted. Of course, many of their own constituents were opposed to their positions, as they actually use the trains.
That's the problem with these towns; only the people who live and work in the towns have the time to serve in the municipal governments, while the actual passengers spend much of the day working in NYC, JC, Newark etc. Only reinforces the parochialism.
rails > roads
On second thought, let's not go to the NJ Transit Rail forum, 'tis a silly place.