george matthews wrote:And volunteers, as most of the workers were, would not want to spend the late hours mucking out a steam engine. There really was a good reason for getting rid of steam. It was very expensive in terms of labour, even if the labour was unpaid.
You're mixing up two completely different things. Of course there was a good reason for getting rid of steam in mainstream commercial service. Nobody disputes that, and to be honest you are once again flogging a dead horse.
But volunteers are generally doing it because they love steam, and throwing out the fire at night is part of the deal. We just want to be around steam engines, even though it is hard and dirty work.
Think of horse lovers. All that shovelling dung and rubbing down sweaty horses. Why don't they just ride motorbikes? Much cleaner, quicker and more efficient. But could it be that they are passionate about horses, and the mucking out and grooming is all about being close to the objects of their passion? Replace the word "horses" with steam engines, and you may begin to understand us!