I read the history of the Tahawus extension with great interest. Thanks for posting it. However, I don't see how that explains any of Curt Austin's "venom" against the S&NC. When he started the idea of a rail trail to Tahawus, the line hadn't been used for nearly 20 years. Once S&NC decided to reopen the line, the rail trail proposal was pretty much shelved with no attempt to join the "green" groups that threatened to stop the reopening due to forest preserve issues.
Also remember that when he suggested Warren County consider a trail for the line to North Creek, IPH said they were losing $1 million a year and had made no move to negotiate a renewal of their lease. The trail idea was only IF the lease wasn't renewed and IF no other operator came along. Since IPH did renew and has continued to operate it's no longer an issue.
As a hiker who occasionally has to look down at the big tailings pile, I would be very happy if IPH could move it all to someplace where it would be useful. However, even though those tailings have already been quarried and crushed, I do still question how that material can be moved such a long distance with a transfer from train to barge and still be competitive with stone that is transported a much shorter distance. I'm not all that convinced that it is just CP that is holding up the deal.
Also remember that when he suggested Warren County consider a trail for the line to North Creek, IPH said they were losing $1 million a year and had made no move to negotiate a renewal of their lease. The trail idea was only IF the lease wasn't renewed and IF no other operator came along. Since IPH did renew and has continued to operate it's no longer an issue.
As a hiker who occasionally has to look down at the big tailings pile, I would be very happy if IPH could move it all to someplace where it would be useful. However, even though those tailings have already been quarried and crushed, I do still question how that material can be moved such a long distance with a transfer from train to barge and still be competitive with stone that is transported a much shorter distance. I'm not all that convinced that it is just CP that is holding up the deal.