I would probably say the same since both rail carriers make the same station stops. Remember, ACE doesn't run on weekends and the existing service isn't convenient. However, service for Amtrak has improved on the CC, but the service is better south of OKJ on weekends.
I agree with you. I would take Amtrak. Ace Rail isnt a well known Company. They dont get a lot of ridership, and they only have 4 trains in each direction.