by TrainManUPRR
Milwaukee West to Elgin then move onto the UP Belvidere Sub at Big Timber up to Rockford.
Railroad Forums
Moderators: metraRI, JamesT4
TrainManUPRR wrote:Milwaukee West to Elgin then move onto the UP Belvidere Sub at Big Timber up to Rockford.and then onto Canadian National if they ever plan on going out to Galena/Iowa
Wingnut wrote:As far as intermingling Amtrak with rush hour Milwaukee West trains go, the nearest model I can think of is Metro-North's Harlem Line which handles an amazing number of express and local trains in just two tracks from Scarsdale all the way to Southeast. The number and spacing of stations is also similar. Despite that, Metro-North manages to put through a Wassaic train in each peak period that makes just three or four stops in this busy area. The comparison continues with the beginning of a three track express zone beginning at Crestwood on Metro-North and River Grove on Metra.Grade separation at A-2 isn't a CREATE project, but it is something Metra has been very interested in for quite sometime. Constructing a flyover or moving the diamonds a mile east are being considered, but given Metra's limited resources and focus on other priorities, A-2 will continue to limp along as is with no extra Amtrak trains to worry about for the time being. That is, per the recent postponement of the new Rockford service...
But by the time trains get to A-5 or A-2, the apparent apple-apple comparison may become apple-orange. I know that CREATE entails a lot of grade separation projects but is the A-2 area one of them?
Wingnut wrote:As far as intermingling Amtrak with rush hour Milwaukee West trains go, the nearest model I can think of is Metro-North's Harlem Line which handles an amazing number of express and local trains in just two tracks from Scarsdale all the way to Southeast. The number and spacing of stations is also similar. Despite that, Metro-North manages to put through a Wassaic train in each peak period that makes just three or four stops in this busy area. The comparison continues with the beginning of a three track express zone beginning at Crestwood on Metro-North and River Grove on Metra.It won't be a CREATE project because none of the freight trains go that far and use A-2, so Metra's on its own for funding.
But by the time trains get to A-5 or A-2, the apparent apple-apple comparison may become apple-orange. I know that CREATE entails a lot of grade separation projects but is the A-2 area one of them?
johndoe780 wrote:Well, at Englewood, Metra crosses some very busy Norfolk Southern tracks and that seems to have been the deciding factor there. The fact that a number of Amtrak trains use that line doesn't hurt either. I have to hand it to Metra for keeping the Milwaukee and UPW lines as on time as they do with the flat junction at A2.Wingnut wrote:As far as intermingling Amtrak with rush hour Milwaukee West trains go, the nearest model I can think of is Metro-North's Harlem Line which handles an amazing number of express and local trains in just two tracks from Scarsdale all the way to Southeast. The number and spacing of stations is also similar. Despite that, Metro-North manages to put through a Wassaic train in each peak period that makes just three or four stops in this busy area. The comparison continues with the beginning of a three track express zone beginning at Crestwood on Metro-North and River Grove on Metra.It won't be a CREATE project because none of the freight trains go that far and use A-2, so Metra's on its own for funding.
But by the time trains get to A-5 or A-2, the apparent apple-apple comparison may become apple-orange. I know that CREATE entails a lot of grade separation projects but is the A-2 area one of them?
I doubt Metra will get as lucky as they did when it came to the Englewood flyover with the feds paying for 95% of the project either.
If Metra wants to run more trains or if Amtrak wants to run more trains or add new trains, especially during rush hour, A-2 is the problem.
johndoe780 wrote: If Metra wants to run more trains or if Amtrak wants to run more trains or add new trains, especially during rush hour, A-2 is the problem.Johndoe, we may have to agree to disagree here. While A-2 is tight and there can be minor delays there, I think, based on observation, that CUS is more capacity constrained than A-2. I've seen days where one of the MD tracks was out of service through A-2 and things still get through with minimal delays. But CUS has times where every track is full: take 4:49pm - if everything is on-time, the 4:48 MD-N has just left Track 1, an MD-W is arriving on 7, and everything else except 19 has a train on it (and 19 has to be kept available for the Empire Builder arrival). And for the next 15 minutes, things don't change very much with a new arrival on a track within one to two minutes after a departure. During that 15 minutes, departures are a mix on 1 Main and 3 Main yet I've seen days where everything had to go out just one of them and yet with only minor delays.
lstone19 wrote:I thought I read that during the upcoming CUS renovation, there was supposed to be something happening on the north tracks to help with some of that traffic during rush hour.johndoe780 wrote: If Metra wants to run more trains or if Amtrak wants to run more trains or add new trains, especially during rush hour, A-2 is the problem.Johndoe, we may have to agree to disagree here. While A-2 is tight and there can be minor delays there, I think, based on observation, that CUS is more capacity constrained than A-2. I've seen days where on the MD tracks was out of service through A-2 and things still get through with minimal delays. But CUS has times where every track is full: take 4:49pm - if everything is on-time, the 4:48 MD-N has just left Track 1, an MD-W is arriving on 7, and everything else except 19 has a train on it (and 19 has to be kept available for the Empire Builder arrival). And for the next 15 minutes, things don't change very much with a new arrival on a track within one to two minutes after a departure. During that 15 minutes, departures are a mix on 1 Main and 3 Main yet I've seen days where everything had to go out just one of them and yet with only minor delays.
From where I sit on my train, you could get one more train through A-2 but getting one more train in and out of CUS is a far more difficult task.
johndoe780 wrote: I thought I read that during the upcoming CUS renovation, there was supposed to be something happening on the north tracks to help with some of that traffic during rush hour.The only thing I've heard about is the idea of removing the baggage platforms and realigning the tracks to make the passenger platforms wider. This is to reduce passenger congestion but won't do anything about train congestion.
I don't think there's anything official, or what they're planning on doing, but that's what I read on the news.