UpperHarlemLine4ever wrote:I am aware of the way the Chicago 3rd rail works. New York used to have the same on it's elevated lines and on lines that had both el and subway cars running. They were all changed over to the covered 3rd rail. I'm looking at it from a safety point of view. Chicago is the only operation that still has the old style, el, 3rd rail. Boston has uncovered 3rd rail but the cars run on a 3rd rail that could be easily covered over (the 3rd rail shoe is as you refer to it as a paddle shoe).
If you say you "you are aware"...then you undoubtedly should be aware that changing our system isn't going to happen for numerous reasons....expensive, time consuming, we have no "safety problems" with our workers, our unions...no benefit in terms of service, equipment apparatus, scheduling, operations car usage, etc. There just is NO REASON.
But I chuckle to myself every six or nine months when the subject comes up on an internet forum...usually form a New York railfan. I hope you are not planning to tresspass onto our rightofway.
CTA PCCs 6201-6510 had paddle shoes for pickup and the current 2200s have a paddle shoe also. But all subsequent orders use the gravity shoe, including our present sidelined order of Boombardier AC5000 series cars.... a design that traces back to England on the 1890s and is still used there I believe. But in addition to the gravity pick up shoe, our sleet cutting devices are also gravity powered, so its not just the pickups.
Thank you for your concern....I am sure you would get the same response from CTA management.
DH