Ryanontherails wrote:F-line to Dudley via Park wrote:The job's run out of Readville, but not as an appendage to the daily yard deliveries. Readville is point of origin for 3 locals: Home Depot/Stoughton, Norwood, and the nighttime weekly to the cold storage warehouse at Widett Circle. Those are the only CSX locals in Eastern MA staged from somewhere other than Framingham or Walpole.
I don't know anything about freight traffic, but if the materials being shipped to and/or from Readville are only on the trains between those three places and Readville and (I assume) are on trucks the rest of the way, then what's the advantage of sending them via rail the few miles that they are? Or am I misunderstanding something?
It's all about where they cluster.
Home Depot's a huge customer. That's the regional lumber distribution warehouse for all of Eastern MA; definitely a Top Five on-line customer for any Eastern MA local of theirs. Enormous facility with a 9-car/3-track main loading pad, overflow loading pad, and their own runaround/yard. And it's literally 1.5 miles from the Readville Yard switch to the Westwood Ind. switch, so serving them is little more than a glorified 'working lunch' in crew commitments...like a yard switcher that just so happens to leave the property for a couple hours. The same industrial track has 2 huge warehouses right next door, currently devoid of rail customers, and couple smaller sidings next to the NEC that haven't yet been claimed by all the mixed-use redevelopment up University Rd. at Westwood Landing. Because Home Depot is such a week-in/week-out profitable run for them they'd be happy to chase new carloads at any one of those Westwood Ind. sidings if a new customer came calling, especially those warehouses adjacent to Home Depot. We have no idea if any customers will come calling, but they'd be easy as all hell to switch wrapped up in a bow with a very profitable anchor next door.
The others are just legacy customers on locals that used to be much bigger but have simply atrophied. The customers have legacy contracts that must be honored; CSX can't refuse them service. But it's not profitable anymore for CSX to serve them because the locals are just too tiny, too irregular, and with too few carloads.
-- Stoughton had a cluster of rail-captive building materials vendors at that industrial park, as well as a slew of sidings up the line in Canton which died out during the late-Conrail era. As described a few posts up, the business is so small we can't even tell who is getting switched anymore at Evans Dr. because it's so intermittent and the companies sharing buildings there are so small. The rest of the industrial biz on that branch is simply gone and been overchurned for bland suburbia like so much New England on-line biz of old that's never ever coming back. CSX has to serve them under time-pressure by Amtrak dispatch to keep to its NEC window, and the running distance makes those couple of mystery cars they drop off down there a decent-size commitment of crew time.
-- Norwood used to have more than just CertainTeed. And CertainTeed, which has a very large siding with track machine, used to be a much larger and less flaky customer than it currently is. That plant must not be running at anywhere near top capacity for how overbuilt its rail infrastructure is compared to current carloads received, and things haven't been the same there since a big worker strike a few years ago. CSX probably does still pocket enough profit from that contract to make it worth their while, but only if CT is getting a steady 4 or 5 cars per week and not going dark for inexplicable reasons. Definitely Hollingsworth going dark has hurt the branch, since things would've looked much more long-term stable with 2 steady customers instead of 1 unreliable one. But Hollingsworth isn't that big and the former siding further up Pleasant St. to gaggle of masonry businesses is long gone, so CertainTeed is holding down the fort. It they go the branch goes; there's no other siding current or former that can replace them as customer justifying the branch's existence.
-- AmeriCold Logistics is the very last of what used to be a much bigger overnight local to South Boston, serving Track 61 (last customer: a small transload on Cypher St. that left town about 6-7 years ago), some industrial crud along Dorchester Ave., a bunch of the food warehouses at Widett Circle and Newmarket, and one long-gone customer in Savin Hill. AmeriCold's owners want to blow up their building to build a recycling center, the City wanted to eminent domain their land for an Olympic stadium back when the Boston 2024 bid was still active, and MassDOT has long coveted that property for MBTA train storage. So nobody...not CSX, not the customer itself, expects to be around in a few years.
Now, the AmeriCold job does have a bigger long-term future in it as Massport is planning to build a rail spur off Track 61 to serve new tenants at redeveloped Marine Terminal once it's finished re-dredging the Harbor for deeper shipping channel. It's a state deal, but CSX has already said it'll serve Marine Terminal nightly out of Readville if the powers that be can produce the customers. Being a port-centric 'cluster' of customers on a common spur fewer than 10 miles from Readville does constitute higher-return business for the effort. Even at modest carloads it helps them much like the short-distance Home Depot job helps them as a short-distance de facto appendage to Readville. So they aren't unilaterally hostile. It's just that inside of I-495 you literally can't count more than Home Depot, Marine T, and anybody small who happens by pure luck to set up next door to Home Depot and Marine T as sites that cluster enough potential together in a bow to keep steady revenue at the decade level.
Everybody else...with possible exception of the industrial park-centric Mansfield-Attleboro NEC mid-afternooner...is just atrophied legacy contracts hitting their evolutionary dead-end. To borrow the famous PAR quote, "chase every carload!", the southside just doesn't have the potential on-line properties even if CSX were gung-ho to "chase every carload". They don't exist anymore. The northside does have some modest on-line opportunities with all the dormant sidings on the NH Main north of Winchester and scattered along the PAR freight main. PAR can say "chase every carload" like there's factual net-gain revenue behind the sentiment. Even if CSX wanted to (and they don't)...their on-line situation is a matter of existence vs. non-existence, not will or enthusiasm. The customers, and the sites for customers, no longer exist down south.