stupid?
no, not really..
as railfans, and Alco fans, and as a huge LV fan myself, it seems like a terrible waste..but thats from our perspective.
we arent in the buisness of running railroads.
but, Conrail and every other railroad of all time has scrapped many thousands of locomotives..its just buisiness.
we cant really say a railroad is "stupid" for doing it..
its just "getting rid of old junk" from the railroad's perspective..
its ususally simply an economic necessity.
many 1957 Chevys were sent to the junkyard in 1967..they were just "used cars" then..no one cared.
today, is it stupid to haul your 1987 beat-up Ford tauris stationwagon to the junkyard?
no, not really..
but in 50 years some ford tauris fan is going to think so!
should you try to locate a museum today that wants your boring Ford stationwagon?
should you keep it in your garage yourself in case future generations want it?
probably not..if its something rare and unique maybe..but not for a regular every-day beater..
those C628's were simply every-day beaters in 1980.
we cant blame the railroads for simply going about their buisness..
and all the railroads that have scrapped thousands of locomotives have also saved and donated a lot too..
Im not sure what Conrail donated specifically, but im sure they donated some things..
I know they donated the LV caboose in Sayre PA for one..
sure, its no C628.. but in 1980, who wanted a C628?
certaintly no railroads wanted any..they were just old junk then.
maybe they could have found a museum who wanted one, but that wasnt really Conrail's concern then..they were more concerned with simply surviving.
we should be happy for the Alcos we still have..no sense lamenting the dead..
sure, maybe Conrail could have done more, at least preserve ONE!
that would have been nice..but it wasnt really their responsibility.
sadly, not everything can be saved..
and we have plently of "preserved" engines today that are simply rusting away on old sidings, with no one to care for them..
not enough volunteers and money to go around for all of the "saved" engines
one could argue there are too many preserved engines as it is..
best to work with what we have..
a LV U23B is coming to Sayre!!
im very excited about that!
and we have several LV C420's still out there..
at least 2 of which are "preserved"..and the rest are still doing their jobs!
Alco preservation is alive and well..
Scot