The boilers on the P&LE Berkshires (Alco's last steam locomotives) LOOK like those on the Niagaras. Some of this resemblance is due to purely cosmetic features: notably, the very flat smokebox front. But there seem to be deeper resemblances as well: most telling, perhaps, is that they have the same maximum diameter (100 inches). The grate area, 88 square feet, could have been obtained by using the same (8 foot) firebox width as the Niagara, but shortening the grate from 12.5 feet to 11 feet. (Grate dimensions in American steam locomotives seem almost always to be multiples of 1/2 foot. I'm not sure why this is so: perhaps design and construction was easier using standardized fire bars? For the historian it gives a helpful shortcut: given the grate area it is usually possible to make a decent guess as to its length and width!)
So, how deep were the similarities? Did they use the same sort of slotted pipe to collect dry steam? (Seems likely: certainly the boilers LOOK domeless.) Did they have combustion chambers, and if so how long? Did they have the same number and diameter of tubes and flues as the Niagaras?
I assume that these locomotives were written up in "Railway Mechanical Engineer" when they were new, but I've never seen any references, or for that matter, any decent drawings of these locomotives.
So, how deep were the similarities? Did they use the same sort of slotted pipe to collect dry steam? (Seems likely: certainly the boilers LOOK domeless.) Did they have combustion chambers, and if so how long? Did they have the same number and diameter of tubes and flues as the Niagaras?
I assume that these locomotives were written up in "Railway Mechanical Engineer" when they were new, but I've never seen any references, or for that matter, any decent drawings of these locomotives.