Discussion relating to the past and present operations of the NYC Subway, PATH, and Staten Island Railway (SIRT).

Moderator: GirlOnTheTrain

  by FRN9
 
Hi everyone,

I am researching what amount of construction it would take to add switches at Hoyt-Schermerhorn so that the A•C trains and the G trains could switch. Does anyone have any ideas on either what it would take to do this or how I could best research this?

Thanks very much<

F
  by Kilgore Trout
 
nycsubway.org has track maps. It looks like there might be room on either side of the station, but it would be a rather tight fit.
  by Passenger
 
I always have wondered what was the reason for the decision not to do this in the first place, particularly considering how over-engineered that station is in a general way.
  by FRN9
 
It doesn't make sense to me either. I think I need to make a visual survey of the approaches from the C and G lines.

Anyone have any knowledge of how switch could be installed in each directly, please holler.
  by keithsy
 
I grew up on this line in the 60's. You could set your watch by a 4 car train of R1-9's The station is not over-engineered. It was designed that way for a reason and everything ran right.
  by DaveBarraza
 
Immediately (compass) East of the station the Crosstown tracks descend, and immediately (compass) West they rise while the Fulton Line tracks go down. The station itself is the only flat area where all 6 tracks are on the same level, so placing switches in the area would be impractical.

Remember that the Crosstown was supposed to have other connections in Williamsburg which would have made service running into Manhattan from Brooklyn less necessary.
  by Passenger
 
keithsy wrote:I grew up on this line in the 60's. You could set your watch by a 4 car train of R1-9's The station is not over-engineered. It was designed that way for a reason and everything ran right.
Not over-engineered?

I grew up in the 60s too. Did you ever see the outer platforms in use?

I mean other than for the Aqueduct special? :wink:
  by Passenger
 
DaveBarraza wrote:Immediately (compass) East of the station the Crosstown tracks descend, and immediately (compass) West they rise while the Fulton Line tracks go down. The station itself is the only flat area where all 6 tracks are on the same level, so placing switches in the area would be impractical.

Remember that the Crosstown was supposed to have other connections in Williamsburg which would have made service running into Manhattan from Brooklyn less necessary.
A real answer. Thank you.