http://www.timesargus.com/apps/pbcs.dll ... 003/NEWS02
Lamoille rail trail plan draws praise, fire
November 29, 2006
By Carla Occaso Times Argus Staff
LYNDON CENTER – A 95-mile multi-use recreation path proposal for a discussed railroad bed connecting St. Johnsbury to Swanton could boost tourism, but sleep deprivation, herbicide use and accessibility dominated public concerns at a hearing Tuesday night.
The proposed Lamoille Valley Rail Trail would allow snowmobiles in winter, but other seasons would be restricted for non-motorized use. Written public comment on the $7 million Lamoille Valley Rail Trail recreation path must be postmarked no later than Dec. 7, said Bryant Watson, executive director of the Vermont Association of Snow Travelers Tuesday night during the final of several public hearings via Vermont Interactive Television.
VAST is the nonprofit organization based in Berlin that oversees snowmobiling in the state, and preserving the trail's use for winter snowmobiling has long been a goal as VAST faces increasing pressures on its 6,000-mile trail system, most of which is on private land.
Participating interactive television sites Tuesday included Johnson, St. Albans, Williston and Lyndonville.
The Vermont Agency of Transportation chose VAST over other organizations bidding to oversee that trail and implement a management plan for its use, Watson said, explaining why VAST is in charge of the statewide recreation project.
Watson said his organization agreed, "to produce and maintain a premier year-round recreation path/trail that will have national and international recognition in U.S. and Canada." Up to 75,000 people could use the trail, Watson estimated.
However the snowmobiling emphasis VAST places on the trail management plan prompted comments from some people who prefer non-motorized use or who own land along the trail.
"Our house is 55 feet from the trail," said Kate Scarlet of East Hardwick "Our cow barn is 50 feet from the trail … we have been woken out in all hours of the night (by snowmobiles)."
Others, including Phil Gimli-Mead of Danville, agreed with Scarlet, saying, "My problem with this whole plan is you guys aren't being good neighbors. … If you want to buy my house, that is fine, but if you are telling be you are going to change the use on that system and subject everyone living along it to staying up all night, I don't believe that is workable."
Responding to criticism from landowners against snowmobiles, Ken Gamell of St. Johnsbury said, "I'm a Caledonia County director for VAST. We do manage 6,000 miles of trail and we have over 10,000 landowners and many are very happy." The project would bring in millions of dollars in tourism and tax money to the state of Vermont, Gammell said.
Only a minor portion of the trail is currently used for snowmobiling, and many of the bridges need to be repaired or replaced, so full development of the trail would open up a whole new corridor for permanent recreation use.
Some of those participating praised VAST for its ability to pull together a plan promising economic development potential that is open to snowmobilers and non-motorized users, including walkers, cross-country skiers, hikers, bicyclists and horseback riders.
"I appreciate VAST branching out … you are obviously expanding the scope of your corporate purpose," a man speaking from the Johnson site said. However he criticized VAST for proposing including the use of herbicide to control brush.
The rail trail would be opened to snowmobiles from 6 a.m. to 11 p.m., prompting some to complain of sleep deprivation while others asked who would enforce speeding and trespassing violations. County Sheriff departments from Caledonia, Franklin and Lamoille counties would work with the Vermont Department of Fish and wildlife "to provide necessary enforcement," Watson said. Individual towns could enact more restrictive speed limits and curfews, he said.
"This past year, Sen. Susan Bartlett, chair of Senate Appropriations Committee, added $25,000 to fund some law enforcement for the Lamoille Valley Recreational Trail," Watson said.
Making the trail accessible to those in wheelchairs concerned some, including Roger Damon of St. Johnsbury, who said, "Rest rooms, including ADA restrooms (and) good surfacing. This will make the difference between something like a rut in the woods and a world class (trail)."
The planned trail surface is Sta-Mat and a "compacted granular surface," Bryant said.
Some expressed concerns about ATVs using the trail, but Watson said ATV use is currently prohibited.
"We envision a rural rail/trail facility which will provide an environment so all users can enjoy nature and the scenic Vermont landscape to its fullest," the plan says. "This environment away from vehicular traffic will become an inviting place where the elderly and persons with disabilities can enjoy more leisurely endeavors and bicycle riders can set their own pace with short rides or multi-day trips."