John - I agree that in the past Metro has evenly circulated the new cars (5000 and 6000) and that likely was because of the dispatch yard and to be fair. And I imagine they will do that again. But, there is 1 difference from the 5000 and 6000 series purchase: if I recall correctly, MWAA itself paid for some of the new 7000 series cars and these cars were intended to service the Silver Line extension because of the fleet constraints you mentioned. When I read the slides, I took them to mean that while 7000 series cars are coming and will be distributed among the fleet, the MWAA paid for 7000 series cars are also coming and will be 'dedicated' to the Silver Line so that new line will be populated by new, shiny cars as soon as possible. It's good PR, I guess.
Since this is Metro's first mass retirement of rolling stock, my biggest interest is how they will go about re-configuring the current consists. Although Metro has a fleet constraint that does not seem to be getting better (as judged by the speed with which they intend to retire the 1000 cars so there will be little excess capacity when 7000 and 1000 series cars overlap), I wonder whether as every 8 car 7000 series train hits the tracks an equal number (8) 1000 cars will be pulled from existing trains and those trains reconfigured. I would hope that Metro will reconfigure the trains to be consists entirely of one model, i.e. all 6000, all 5000, etc. I rode a 6 car train of all 6000 series cars this morning, and it was noticeably better.
Back to the fast retirement of the 1000 series, which leads to less excess capacity even with the 7000 series cars arriving. As you note, it would be better to have excess capacity for all of the reasons you mention. I just wonder whether, as I noted in my post before your post, Metro is simply sick and tired of the 1000 series cars and wants to get them out of here as fast as possible. 2017 is not really that far off when you think of it. As I noted, I wonder whether Metro's thinking is that a large, flexible fleet of 1000 AND 7000 cars (and space to store them all) is outweighed by getting the 1000 series (and all of their problems) off the rails, never to return, and relying on the 7000 series trains to pull the extra load, which they should be able to handle because they're new. I also thought it was interesting that the 4000 series was only mentioned once (pg 10) in connection with the 1000 series cars being retired, but it was not mentioned again elsewhere with specific dates.
Living in Broadlands, VA; Working at Half & L SE, DC.