by bth8446
Wow, those pictures of the track ballast being washed away from under the tracks that septa, news and other outlets showed, were interesting.
Makes me wonder if a solution could be made, or perhaps there is already a solution.
I assume packed rocky soil, then a few feet of ballast is the most economical track bed for any lenght of weather exposed track.
so I don't think we are going to change that.
I looked at the pictures and I thought, how about, in areas where they know there are washout issues (they know of some, I'm sure
others need the right conditions before they are identified, but certainly we just discovered a few this past week) how about laying down some kind of adhesive. When they put on the last foot of ballast in these areas, apply it with some gooey adhesive that will harden up (a bit, but not too much) so that when water comes along in a gush, it can still pass through the ballast but won't wash it away. The adhesive would keep the ballast stuck together at its contact points to other ballast rocks next to it.
Does such a substance exist that won't wear away in harsh heat, water, snow, ice, freezing temps, constant flex from heavy trains compressing them . . .? I don't know.
It couldn't be applied system wide, it would probably make track and tie renewal difficult. but if applied at just the problemed areas,
I don't think it would be that bad.
Perhaps it is most economical to just take the puch in the system's face and go out of service for a day or two. How often do washouts
recur at the same troubled locations?
Or was this situation quite unique?
Anyone know of a recurring trouble spot?
Makes me wonder if a solution could be made, or perhaps there is already a solution.
I assume packed rocky soil, then a few feet of ballast is the most economical track bed for any lenght of weather exposed track.
so I don't think we are going to change that.
I looked at the pictures and I thought, how about, in areas where they know there are washout issues (they know of some, I'm sure
others need the right conditions before they are identified, but certainly we just discovered a few this past week) how about laying down some kind of adhesive. When they put on the last foot of ballast in these areas, apply it with some gooey adhesive that will harden up (a bit, but not too much) so that when water comes along in a gush, it can still pass through the ballast but won't wash it away. The adhesive would keep the ballast stuck together at its contact points to other ballast rocks next to it.
Does such a substance exist that won't wear away in harsh heat, water, snow, ice, freezing temps, constant flex from heavy trains compressing them . . .? I don't know.
It couldn't be applied system wide, it would probably make track and tie renewal difficult. but if applied at just the problemed areas,
I don't think it would be that bad.
Perhaps it is most economical to just take the puch in the system's face and go out of service for a day or two. How often do washouts
recur at the same troubled locations?
Or was this situation quite unique?
Anyone know of a recurring trouble spot?